Issue No 17, Nov 11-17, 2002 | ISSN:1684-2075 | satribune.com

Innovesia - International Savings Program

Opinion

 

From Musharraf's 'Sham to Shame', but What Now

Shaheen Sehbai

General Pervez Musharraf came into power, holding a gun, blaming the “sham democracy” and “sham politicians” and promising “real democracy”. Where he has taken us is South. What we have today in Pakistan is worse than what General Musharraf inherited.

We have a President who claims to be elected for 5 years on the basis of a fraudulent referendum in which even minors were permitted to vote after all restrictions were lifted. Is this the “real democracy” he promised.

We have a set of politicians who are touted as the “King’s Party” but who are opportunist, corrupt and shameless individuals who defected from their parent party just to save their skins. These seekers of perks, power and privileges today have got immense political clout as a bonus.

We have a set of Generals who are now begging erstwhile political untouchables, like the Maulanas of NWFP and Asif Ali Zardari, just because the voters upset their calculations and machinations and these forces got so many seats the Generals could never imagine, or concede, in their well-calculated and engineered elections.

We have a set of ministers who say, day in and day out, that if politicians do not change their loyalties the doors for horse trading will be officially and legally opened. In fact the Law Minister now says the floor crossing law is in abeyance so he is encouraging defections. Is that the form and shape of “real democracy” Musharraf wanted.

We have this set of Maulanas who are now serious players in the political game, after they and their Afghan associates, the Taliban and Osama & Co, were bombed out by the Americans and Musharraf brigades. The Generals of Pakistan did not pay enough attention to this growing threat because they were busy consolidating their political positions and seats of power in Pakistan for years to come.

In all this mess General Musharraf now seems drowned up to his neck and his junta colleagues are watching with confusion and bewilderment, disbelief writ on their faces, not knowing how to react, whether to allow Musharraf to continue with his failing and flailing games or to put an end to the continuing charade and start putting the derailed country back on the tracks.

The political dish of scrambled eggs Musharraf wants to cook is almost impossible to digest, even if he buys, begs or steals votes and numbers to cobble together a coalition of supporters. He and his political experts have proved themselves to be men with no ideas and ideals, no principles and morals, no goals and vision, no trust in the future or destiny of the nation. They are pure and simple petty power seekers, not in any way better than the politicians and their cronies who they had overthrown in the name of “good governance” and “real democracy”.

The entire exercise Musharraf has carried out, and the manner in which it has been carried out, has discredited him and his ways, bringing him in line with Generals who forced themselves on the nation before him and who left the country in a much bigger mess than they had come. Musharraf is doing nothing different or better.

He now has few options and fewer days and weeks to still set the direction right, if he still wants to go down in history as a well meaning person who was thrust into power “without any prior plans”, as he claimed, and who wanted to set things right.

The first thing he needs to do is to declare a general amnesty for all politicians and announce that he would not stay on if he was not elected through the normal process. He should present himself for elections.

Then he should meet all the major political players to draw up a package of basic institutional reforms for the judiciary which has to assume the role of key neutral arbitrator on all critical national legal and constitutional issues.

All judges of the Supreme Court should be sent home and an absolutely transparent and open process should be initiated to induct new and qualified judges, from the present lot and from outside, purely on merit, so that they do not owe any obligation to any particular person or government. This new bench should then decide any legal, constitutional and national matter referred to it by any citizen.

All corruption cases against the politicians, generals, bureaucrats and everybody else, should be handed over to these new judges and let their decisions be final, again purely on evidence and merits of each case.

Parliament, as elected by the people, though under very dubious circumstances, should be allowed to function under the 1973 constitution and General Musharraf should present himself as a candidate for the President’s office.

Army should be pulled out of politics and a purely professional and apolitical army chief be appointed who should take oath before the new Supreme Court declaring that he would under no circumstances indulge in politics.

The Press should be allowed to work freely under a code of ethics framed by the peers themselves and not by the Government. It is certainly going to conduct itself in the most responsible manner, if given that opportunity.

All this may seem to be utopia to many in the present messy conditions when a rat race to grab power, or even a small part of it, is making the country look like a split banana republic, with the banana already peeled naked. "Principle" is the one word missing from the dictionaries of Pakistan.

The politicians in their quest for authority are bending backwards and stooping to the lowest depth of meanness and debauchery.

The Generals in their drive to stay on top are compromising the image and reputation of the entire institution of the armed forces, although it may be a debatable point whether any respect and dignity is left to preserve.

The Judges in their pursuit of survival are shamelessly using the “Doctrine of Necessity” to its limit, forgetting that whenever a senior judge goes out of office, he has to face the same indignity and injustice as others did when he was denying them a fair trial and opportunity.

It is time the Doctrine of Necessity was used in the interest of the people of Pakistan, for a change. It should be made clear that in 1999, under this very Doctrine, Pakistani people accepted the Army intervention, its unconstitutional amendments, its crooked ground rules and self-serving orders, only to see the country get back on the democratic track. Now that it has got an elected parliament, these temporary rules and regulations are no longer valid or needed and the system which has to last for ever must be revived.

It is time Pakistan was put back as a respectable, dignified and responsible nation on the world map. It had enough of failed experiments. Let us settle down and start some real nation building.


Email story  Email Story | Discuss story Discuss Story

Back to top

 

This Site Is

Innovesia

Copyright © 2002 South Asia Tribune Publications, L.L.C. All rights reserved.